Jake Hoffman
Per. 3
9/8/13
Beowulf and the Tales of Heroes Past
Heroes of any generation have some
defining characteristic that make them unique to their time period and culture,
as a formula for heroes this can be seen in both the epic heroes of old, like
Beowulf, and the modern heroes, let’s say Cpt. America. Both these heroes are shining examples of the
time period of their creation, and as such show traits held in priority to the
social expectations of their respective culture. For example, the courage and
wisdom of Beowulf was characterized as a Nordic hero, while the patriotism of
Cpt. America was the embodiment of pride in the time of World War Two. Both heroes
were figure heads of their cultures through courage, and strength of heart and
mind.
Cultures revolve around symbols of
honor and superiority, the strength of Beowulf helped him become legend because
his inhuman strength allowed him the opportunity to disarm Grendel, or so to
speak. “Then
farther he hied; for the hardy hero with hand he grasped, felt for the foe with
fiendish claw, for the hero reclining, -- who clutched it boldly, prompt to
answer, propped on his arm.” However it does not mean his
power is used for misdeeds, rather the story is told in such a light as to show
that He was no more human than us, an ethological effect also used by Stan Lee
in the creation of the Capitan. Stan Lee made the comic book hero an average
Joe to show that the hero could be just like you.
Heroes
also present a precognitive type of knowledge system in older epics. It seems
as if Beowulf knew his fate before the events unfolded. This occurred in many
accounts such as the final assault on the dragon when Beowulf told his
companion of his death, and the prediction of slaying Grendel with his bare
hands. While it may seem cocky to boast about your achievements in current
times, it was seen as a resume in the time of the old tribes. It would be a massive faux pas to give the
boasting characteristics to the symbol of America during the war, so Capitan
America was given more subtle implications of greatness, a sort of trust that
the readers would understand His credentials. Furthermore Capitan America, as a
comic book, has no chance of allowing the imagery created in Beowulf (however
hard to understand).
All
in all, heroes generally stay the same, only minute changes occur to fit the
era that they were created in. If a society wants a genius, they make one,
while if a society wants strength beyond measure, they call in the spandex.
Once again, another good super hero comparison essay, however, I think that maybe could have used more emphasis on Captain America, I felt like the essay was more about Beowulf, and just lightly touching on Captain American. But it was still a good read.
ReplyDeleteGreat essay, I liked the "matter of fact" style opening, and your word choice throughout. Some things I would suggest, though, are making more of a connection between Captain America and Beowulf. Think of it as that you know that Beowulf is an epic hero, but that you are trying to prove that Captain America is through your essay. Also, the essay would look a bit more professional if you spell out Captain America instead of abbreviating captain. God essay!
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed your essay, and I like how your literary techniques don't seem to be atypical or to cliche. On a tangent off one of Daniel's statement is writing out Captain America- I personally don't mind if it's spelled "Capt." throughout the essay, but "Captain" is his name and not just a title.
ReplyDeleteJake, This is a good essay.Once again I am shocked about how many heroes Beowulf can be compared to, the only one I could think of was IronMan. I have to agree with some of the comments before me, adding more emphasis to Captain America would help the reader get a better sense of the comparisons between the two characters. I also agree with the comment about spelling out Captain, but only because it is his name. Other then those minor things I thought your essay was full of great examples and details that helped support your examples! Good job!
ReplyDeleteI agree with the previous comments, here are a couple specific suggestions: 1) Consider refining your introduction by shortening your sentences (e.g., ending the first sentence with "culture) so as to set off each idea in the reader's mind before s/he continues to your next thought; and 2) As we develop more expertise in literary elements, discuss each character as a function of tools such as in/direct characterization, figurative language, et al.
ReplyDelete